BlogHer07 in Chicago - Day One: Breakout #3 Session Art of Life: Art of Writing Reviews.
Many, many bloggers write reviews for fun and for money. Some traditional journalists think the art of criticism is dying, and deplore its demise, but studies show that people put as much stock in what their neighbors think of a product, service or piece of entertainment as they do in what a "professional" thinks. Whether just-the-facts-ma'am new product reviews or more subjective and artful entertainment reviews, bloggers are telling you what they think.
Maria Niles - moderator (who blogs at Fizz from Consumer Pop)
Barb Dybwad (who blogs at Weblogs, Inc. at AOL, Joystiq, geeked., and Engadget)
Claire Zulkey (who blogs at Zukley.com and is a L.A. Times TV reviewer/blogger at Show Tracker)
Eugenia Williamson (who blogs at Literago - Literate Chicago and writes at Time Out Chicago)
If you attended the session and want to provide a link to your review blog, please do so in the comments below.
Q: What makes a review? Do you have to be a pro or trained? Can bloggers be reviewers? Is there a standard for legit criticism?
Barb - At Engadget, we give "opinions as a friend" but do have standards as to what is covered and how it's formatted. We're not afraid to tell it like it is.
Eugenia - She writes professionally as a reviewer, but on Literago - Literate Chicago they do reviews of literary events which is kind of different.
Claire: LA Times editors didn't want to do recaps, but a little more - a "piece" and a review. She tries to take it seriously and wants to report more than just the facts.
Metromix.com - reviewers are readers, reader driven content. Good place for practice. Sharing your opinion in an articulate, non-inflammatory way.
Q: (Audience - Heidi O'Connor) What else are you injecting into your reviews to make it more personal?
Claire - Interviews with the contestants, comparisions between similar shows, adding little stories from the show to add to opinion. The LA Times wants to make the content interesting even to people who don't watch the show.
Barb - Engadget compares their review products to similar products, subjective analysis, how the device fits into her life, then zoom out and show how the product would be used in other situations that make it more general.
Q: (Liz Rizzo - Everyday Goddess - she is trying book reviews and tv shows. However, she feels like a poseur because of a need to summarize the book/show. It seems boring and too much work. How should she handle this?
Eugenia - Plot summaries are boring, keep them short, read big reviewers and see how they handle this, don't give away the plot, no spoilers, good writing
Claire - in TV you have to summarize and give spoilers. Imagine how you would tell your friend about this show and write it that way.
Maria - Television without Pity - recaps/summaries and TV Squad - reviews - look at what other's are doing.
Commentary - Reviewer from Literary Mama - either make the review personal or political. Take the theme and take it to a personal level and relate it to you. Tell your story or make a political/societal point.
Claire - Take it personal.
Eugenia - Look at who you are writing for.